Guide
·
TPRM/Vendor

The Biggest Challenges in Vendor Risk Management (and How to Fix Each)

The 7 biggest vendor risk management challenges in 2026, from questionnaire fatigue to fourth parties and DPDP, with a CISO's fix for each one.

Chief Product Officer
Published
November 2, 2026
Reading time
13
min

TL;DR

The biggest challenges in vendor risk management in 2026 are the old ones, now more expensive. Third parties were involved in 48% of breaches in Verizon's 2026 DBIR. Seven problems matter most: questionnaire fatigue, fourth and nth parties you can't see, assessments that go stale, contracts that don't carry the risk, weak tiering, AI vendors and shadow AI, and regulation that now names you as responsible for your processors. Fix tiering first, because every other fix depends on knowing which vendors deserve the effort.

Full disclosure: we build Redacto, and it includes vendor risk software. The challenges and fixes below are my view, and they apply whatever tool you use.

Nearly half of breaches now run through a vendor

Your organisation probably shares customer data with more vendors than anyone on the risk team can name from memory. Every one of them is a door you don't control, and attackers have noticed. In the 2026 Verizon Data Breach Investigations Report, breaches involving a third party rose 60% and now account for 48% of all breaches.

You're here because you want a current, honest list of the biggest challenges in vendor risk management, and some sense of what to do about each one. For each one you'll get the fix I'd push for as a CISO, the regulation that makes it urgent in 2026, and the order I'd take them on in.

The short answer

The biggest vendor risk management challenges are questionnaire fatigue, no view of fourth and nth parties, stale assessments, contracts that don't carry the risk, poor vendor tiering, AI vendors and shadow AI, and regulation (DPDP, RBI outsourcing rules, DORA, HIPAA) that holds you responsible for vendor failures. Underneath all seven is one problem: too few people chasing too many vendors with the same effort for each.

If you're new to the discipline, start with what third-party risk management covers. Vendor risk management is the part of it focused on suppliers you pay. Supplier risk management in procurement also covers price, delivery and financial stability, while vendor risk management cares most about data, security and continuity.

Vendor risk management trends in 2026: why it got harder

Three changes made vendor risk harder in 2026.

Attacks through vendors became routine. The 2026 DBIR puts third-party involvement at 48% of breaches, and for the first time in its 19 editions it found exploitation of software vulnerabilities (31%) ahead of stolen credentials as the top way in. Vendors run a lot of that software.

Verizon 2026 DBIR release with the third-party share of breaches (48%, up 60%) marked; verizon.com, 29 Oct 2026
Marked: third-party involvement in breaches is up 60% and now accounts for 48% of all breaches. Verizon, 2026 DBIR release, captured 29 Oct 2026.

They also cost more and take longer. IBM's Cost of a Data Breach Report 2026 puts the global average breach at USD 4.99 million. Supply chain compromise was the second most common attack vector, averaged USD 4.96 million and took 258 days to identify and contain. In India, IBM found the average breach reached ₹25.5 crore, and supply chain compromise was behind 15% of them.

And regulators stopped accepting "the vendor did it". India's DPDP Rules start applying in full on 13 May 2027, RBI reissued its outsourcing rules as new Directions in November 2025, and the EU named its first critical ICT providers under DORA. That's why vendor risk matters to supply chain management as much as to security: one weak supplier can now stop operations and draw a regulatory finding in the same week.

Which industries are most affected by third-party risk? IBM's 2026 data ranks healthcare as the costliest sector for breaches for the 13th year running (USD 6.64 million), with financial services next (USD 6.29 million). Both share sensitive data with long vendor chains, and both have regulators who now ask about them by name.

Challenge 1: Questionnaire fatigue and low-quality answers

Why it happens

Every customer sends its own spreadsheet of questions, often hundreds long, so vendors build a library of stock answers and paste them in. Your analysts then read hundreds of "Yes, see policy" replies with no evidence attached. The vendor is tired, your team is tired, and the questionnaire tells you very little.

The tools don't always help, and the people using the big third-party risk platforms say so (Gartner Peer Insights, October 2026). Users on Gartner like how configurable ProcessUnity is and complain that its process flows need careful planning and aren't plug-and-play. OneTrust users like the ready-made templates and complain that each platform update needs admin tweaks. Panorays users like the easy deployment and complain that they can't see why something was flagged. Black Kite users like the supply-chain visibility and complain about vulnerability findings that are outdated or wrong. That's the real challenge large companies face with vendor risk software: setup effort and scores that don't explain themselves. I'd test both in any trial before I looked at a dashboard.

The fix

Ask fewer questions, and ask for proof. Use a standard set such as the SIG questionnaire and scope it to the vendor's tier. Accept an independent audit report (SOC 2 Type II or an ISO 27001 certificate with its statement of applicability) in place of the questions it already answers. Spend your analysts' time on the gaps.

Automation is the other half, and it's where the "how do I automate vendor risk management" question really lands. Tools that read a vendor's existing reports and draft answers with the source page attached cut most of the copying. A reviewer still decides, and we look at what that change means in how AI is changing vendor security reviews. We cover the options in how to automate vendor risk management.

Challenge 2: You can't see fourth and nth parties

Your contract is with the vendor. Your data, though, often sits with the vendor's cloud host, its email provider, its support desk and, more and more often, an AI model API. Those are fourth parties, and their own providers are nth parties. Most programmes can name their third parties and very few can name the fourth.

Redacto diagram of a vendor chain: you, your vendor, its sub-processors and shared nth-party providers
Redacto diagram. Concentration example from Reuters reporting on the C-Edge incident, 31 Jul 2024.

Concentration risk

The quieter danger is concentration: one provider sitting behind many of your vendors, or behind a whole sector. On 31 July 2024 NPCI isolated C-Edge Technologies, a technology provider to cooperative and regional rural banks, after a ransomware attack. Reuters reported that about 300 small banks briefly lost payment services. Most of those banks would never have listed the attacker's entry point as their own vendor.

The fix

For every critical vendor, get the sub-processor list in the contract and a duty to tell you before a new one is added. Flow your breach-notice and security terms down to them. Then do the step most teams skip: cross-reference sub-processor lists across your vendor base, so you can see when ten "different" suppliers all depend on the same provider.

Indian banks already have to do this: RBI's 2025 outsourcing Directions require the bank's prior approval before a service provider engages a subcontractor.

Challenge 3: Assessments go stale the day they're filed

A vendor assessment is a photograph. By the time it's approved, the vendor has shipped new code, changed sub-processors and maybe been breached. Annual reviews leave eleven months of blind spots, and many vendors outside the top tier never get reassessed at all.

This is where vendor risk assessment challenges bite hardest. Due diligence happens once, ongoing monitoring is thin, and remediation items get logged and forgotten.

The fix

Treat the assessment as the start of a record. Add continuous monitoring for your critical tier (external security ratings, breach news, certificate expiry), and define events that force a reassessment: a breach at the vendor, a new sub-processor, a change of ownership, a new type of data. Track every remediation item with an owner and a date, and close the loop at the next review.

If you're a bank or NBFC comparing vendor risk platforms, test them on exactly these three things. Due diligence should pull evidence rather than only send questionnaires. Ongoing monitoring should raise an alert you can act on. Remediation tracking should show who promised what, by when, and whether they delivered. A platform that does one of these well and the others poorly will leave gaps an inspector will find.

Challenge 4: Contracts don't carry the risk

Most vendor contracts were written by procurement for price and service levels. Security and privacy show up as a schedule nobody negotiates. When something goes wrong, you find there's no breach-notice deadline, no audit right, no say over sub-processors and no clause on returning or deleting data.

The fix is a standard data protection and security schedule, scaled by tier, that the business can't strip out. At minimum for critical vendors: breach notice within hours, not "without undue delay"; audit and evidence rights; sub-processor approval; data deletion and return at exit; and help with an orderly exit. Our guide on embedding accountability in third-party contracts goes clause by clause.

For Indian companies there's a legal reason as well as an operational one. Rule 6(1)(f) of the DPDP Rules requires an appropriate provision in your contract with each Data Processor for taking reasonable security safeguards. Rule 7 gives you 72 hours from becoming aware of a breach to send the Data Protection Board a detailed report, unless the Board allows longer. You can't meet that if your vendor tells you on day five.

Challenge 5: Too many vendors, too little tiering

Most teams run the same process for the catering company and the core banking provider. The result is predictable: the critical vendors get the same shallow review as everyone else, and the analysts drown.

Redacto vendor tiering table: criteria, assessment depth and reassessment cadence for four tiers
Redacto table. Cadences are a starting point, not a regulatory minimum.

Tier on two things only: what data the vendor touches, and how long you could operate without it. The table above is the starting point I'd use. Tier 1 is usually a small fraction of the list, and it should get most of the effort.

For mid-market businesses scaling fast

The operational challenge for a mid-market business as it scales is that the vendor list grows faster than the team. New SaaS tools arrive through credit cards, not procurement. My advice is to tie tiering to vendor intake: no vendor gets access to production data or customer records until it has a tier, an owner and a contract schedule. That one gate prevents most of the clean-up work later.

Challenge 6: AI vendors and shadow AI

AI changed vendor risk in two ways. Vendors you already use are adding AI features that send your data to model providers you've never assessed. And your own staff are pasting data into AI tools nobody approved. The 2026 DBIR found that use of unapproved "shadow AI" tools rose from 15% to 45% of employees in a single year, and it's now the third most common non-malicious data leakage activity.

Regulators are paying attention. The RBI's FREE-AI committee report (August 2025) sets out an approach to responsible AI in financial services, including how regulated entities should govern AI they source from third parties.

RBI FREE-AI committee report page, title and 13 Aug 2025 date marked; rbi.org.in, 29 Oct 2026
Marked: the FREE-AI committee report title and its 13 Aug 2025 date. Reserve Bank of India, FREE-AI committee report, captured 29 Oct 2026.

The fix starts with three questions for every vendor: does the product use AI on our data, which model providers receive it, and is our data used to train their models? Add them to your questionnaire and make the answers contractual. For shadow AI, publish an approved-tools list and block the rest at the proxy, because a policy alone won't hold. If you're using AI to run the assessments themselves, our review of AI tools for vendor security assessments covers what works.

Challenge 7: Regulation now makes vendor failures yours

This is the challenge that has changed most in India. The DPDP Act is explicit. Section 8(1) makes the Data Fiduciary responsible for complying with the Act "in respect of any processing undertaken by it or on its behalf by a Data Processor", irrespective of any agreement to the contrary. Section 8(2) lets you use a processor only under a valid contract.

DPDP Act Section 8(1), processor-responsibility phrases marked; MeitY Gazette copy, captured 29 Oct 2026
Marked: (1) "irrespective of any agreement to the contrary" and (2) "on its behalf by a Data Processor" in Section 8(1). DPDP Act 2023, Gazette copy published by MeitY, p. 7, taken from the PDF 29 Oct 2026.

The DPDP Rules 2025 add the detail. Rule 6 requires reasonable security safeguards, including over processing by a Data Processor, with logs kept for a year and a contract clause requiring them. Rule 7 sets a 72-hour deadline for the detailed breach report to the Board, unless the Board allows longer. Most of these duties apply from 13 May 2027. The penalty for failing to take reasonable security safeguards goes up to ₹250 crore. Our explainer on data processors under the DPDP Act covers the processor side.

MeitY DPDP Rules 2025 page, the Rules and enforcement timeline marked; meity.gov.in, 26 Oct 2026
Marked: (1) the Digital Personal Data Protection Rules, 2025 and (2) the enforcement timeline for the DPDP Act. MeitY, DPDP Rules 2025 page, captured 26 Oct 2026.

Financial services carry a second layer. The RBI's Managing Risks in Outsourcing Directions, 2025 for commercial banks require due diligence when you consider or renew an outsourcing arrangement, an evaluation that covers the provider's subcontractors, and independent reviews and market feedback where useful. Banks with EU operations also face DORA, which has applied since 17 January 2025; on 18 November 2025 the European supervisory authorities designated 19 critical ICT third-party providers for direct oversight.

RBI Outsourcing Directions 2025, paras 30(vi) and 31 marked; rbi.org.in, captured 29 Oct 2026
Marked: (1) paragraph 30(vi), the provider's due diligence on its employees and sub-contractors, and (2) paragraph 31, independent reviews and market feedback. Reserve Bank of India, Managing Risks in Outsourcing Directions 2025, captured 29 Oct 2026.

Vendor risk management in insurance

Insurers carry the same exposure through brokers, third-party administrators and claims processors, all of which hold policyholder health and financial data. Vendor risk management in insurance comes down to the same seven problems, with more of the data held outside the company than inside it. Map every broker, TPA and claims processor to a tier, and make breach notice and sub-processor approval contractual for each, because the policyholder data they hold is still yours under DPDP Section 8(1).

One control set for every regulator

Build one control set that maps to all of these, rather than one programme per regulator. Due diligence, contract clauses, monitoring, breach notice and exit plans are the same work whether DPDP, RBI or DORA asks for it.

Healthcare vendor risk challenges

Healthcare has every challenge above, with higher stakes. Hospitals and insurers rely on billing companies, claims clearinghouses, cloud EHR hosts, labs, and now AI scribes and coding tools. Each of them is a business associate handling protected health information.

The Change Healthcare attack showed what concentration risk looks like in health. The clearinghouse processed claims for providers across the US, and on 31 July 2025 it told the HHS Office for Civil Rights that about 192.7 million individuals were affected. If you're evaluating claims management vendors for a high-volume payer, test them as Tier 1: ask for their sub-processor list, their recovery time if they go offline, and how they'd notify you of a breach.

Under HIPAA, covered entities and their business associates both have to give notice after a breach of unsecured health information.

HHS Breach Notification Rule page, business associates' notice duty marked; hhs.gov, 29 Oct 2026
Marked: covered entities and their business associates must give notice after a breach of unsecured protected health information. U.S. HHS, Breach Notification Rule, captured 29 Oct 2026.

The bar may rise. HHS's December 2024 proposal to update the HIPAA Security Rule would require business associates to verify, at least once every 12 months, that they've deployed the required technical safeguards, through a written analysis by a subject-matter expert and a written certification. It's still a proposal; HHS's regulatory agenda now points to a final rule in July 2027.

HHS HIPAA Security Rule proposal, annual business associate verification marked; hhs.gov, 29 Oct 2026
Marked: the proposal that business associates verify their security measures at least once every 12 months. U.S. HHS, HIPAA Security Rule NPRM fact sheet (Dec 2024), captured 29 Oct 2026.

How does vendor security management in healthcare differ from fintech? Fintech vendor risk is shaped by regulators who inspect outsourcing and by the need to keep payment systems running. Healthcare risk is shaped by patient data volumes, legacy clinical systems that vendors can't easily patch, and AI tools arriving faster than procurement can review them. For AI vendor risk assessment in healthcare, ask where audio and notes are processed, whether they train models, and how long they're kept. Indian hospitals have the DPDP layer on top; see our DPDP guidelines for healthcare.

Which challenge to fix first

If I had one quarter and a small team, this is the order I'd follow. It's also my short list of vendor risk management best practices.

  1. Tier the vendor list. Nothing else works until you know which few vendors deserve most of the effort.
  2. Fix the contracts for Tier 1 at the next renewal: breach notice in hours, audit rights, sub-processor control, deletion and exit.
  3. Get sub-processor lists from Tier 1 and look for shared providers.
  4. Replace long questionnaires with tiered ones plus evidence, and automate the drafting.
  5. Add monitoring and event-based reassessment for Tier 1.
  6. Add AI questions to every assessment and an approved-tools list for staff.
  7. Map the whole thing once to DPDP, RBI and any other regulator you answer to.

What's the best third-party risk software for regulated sectors? The one that fits this order: evidence-based assessments, sub-processor tracking, monitoring and an audit trail your regulator will accept. Compare the options in our roundup of third-party vendor risk management software, and if you're starting from scratch, read how to build a third-party risk management program.

If you'd like to see vendor assessments drafted from the evidence your vendors already sent, book a vendor risk demo with Redacto.

Get the practical version, monthly.

One email a month on what changed in Indian privacy practice.

One email a month. Unsubscribe in one click.
You are on the list. The next issue lands at the start of the month.
That did not go through. Check the email address and try again.
See it against your own data

Thirty minutes. We map one of your processing activities end to end.

Book a demo